A Person’s a Person, No Matter How Small
“Underweight,” “Off the chart,” “Failure to thrive” - all of these I have heard in the past year regarding Sam’s size. For months I have been trying to get him to gain weight because he is not high enough on “the chart.” Oh, the chart, the all important chart. Last summer, when this all began, our pediatrician wanted me to put Sam on a high calorie diet in order to get his weight back up. I was pregnant at the time, emotional. The whole thing really took me by surprise. I was particularly confused about the manner in which she wanted me to get him to gain. It involved a lot of sugar and a lot of products like Instant Breakfast. I ended up doing a modified version of it, focusing more on increasing his fat intake, and in six weeks he gained a whole pound. I was told to continue with this diet in hopes that he would creep up even higher.
Fast forward to January. At this particular doctor appointment I found out that Sam had not gained what she would have liked him to. I explained that at his last visit he had been weighed on the big scale and was fully dressed, whereas this time around he was on the sitting scale and in a diaper. Still not good enough. I asked if he appeared unhealthy in any way. No, but too low on the chart. She started talking about having him tested for reflux, also known as a milk scan. As she explained it, this was just a precautionary measure to be certain there was not a physical problem that was stopping him from gaining weight. She assured me it was a simple, safe test, and that there was no harm in having it done to be sure everything was ok. He probably wouldn’t have reflux, but we should do it just to be sure. If the reflux test was negative we should move on to a special feeding clinic where he would have behavioral evaluations and put on some sort of program to get him to eat more. I went home overwhelmed and upset. I’d already been trying so hard to balance what she wanted me to do with what I felt was right for him, and this felt like I’d failed after being given an ultimatum.
After I had some time to regroup and get over how shamed I felt (she also tried to make me feel stupid about Robby’s alternative vaccine schedule, which she had originally said she supported, but that’s another post), I just had the feeling that something was off. You know, when you just don’t feel right and are unsure as to why?
I started writing down everything that Sam ate each day. I wasn’t sure what I was going to do with it, but I had a feeling I might need it at some point if I was going to deviate at all from our doctor’s plan for him. I also started doing a little bit of research on reflux. When I compared what I was finding out to what he was eating in a day, there was just no way that it was the problem. He was eating quite a bit and taking in a wide range of foods. More importantly, I called the hospital to find out exactly what the test entailed, and that’s when I discovered why I felt so odd at the appointment with her.
Remember, our doctor told us the test was not a big deal. She said it was simple and safe. She said I’d just need to bring a cup of milk for him to drink. What she failed to mention was that first a radioactive material would be put in his milk. I was assured by the woman on the phone that this was “perfectly safe,” that the amount of radioactive material was so little that they “just dumped it down the sink.” I don’t even know what that is supposed to mean. And it doesn’t matter because of what would happen next. After drinking his radioactive milk Sam was going to then be strapped down onto a table . . . for an HOUR . . . while they x-rayed him to watch what the glow in the dark milk did inside his system. Can you imagine? He’s two and a half. He was going to have belts going across his chest holding him onto a table tight enough that he would not be able to move insane asylum style. I was told that I could bring some books to read to help sooth him. Yeah, that’ll work. I spoke to a friend of mine later and found out that her son had this test done. She said it was completely traumatizing for both of them. She had to leave the room several times and begged her husband to unbuckle her son so she could take him and run away. She also said there was no way the test would not have come up positive because her son was so upset that he made himself vomit. Did my doctor think I wouldn’t find out what the test really entailed? I just can’t believe that this woman could stand there and tell me it was not a big deal. We’ll not be seeing her again.
I called the doctor. She wasn’t in. I spoke to her colleague. I read my food log to her and she agreed that he most likely did not have reflux and agreed there would be no reason to undergo “that test” when he was not demonstrating any symptoms for that problem. She recommended I take him to a nutritionist in order to make sure that what she thought sounded like a great diet really was one and to discuss other reasons he might not be gaining.
Sam had his first appointment with the nutritionist a few weeks ago. She agreed that he seemed very healthy and had an excellent diet, but that he was small. She gave me some more tips on how to get him to take in more calories. We’re going to keep checking his weight in hopes of getting him higher on the chart. It feels slightly less like an ultimatum, but I certainly still feel very much under pressure here. And constant discussion about Sam’s eating certainly does not help things. As any of you with a child this age knows, the more you push the worse it gets. So I’m trying to settle down about the whole thing and trust myself to do what is best for him.
_______________________________________________________________________________
And here’s the happy side of this post, also appropriate under the same title. Sam and I had a little Mommy/Sammy date today. I took him to see his first movie, Horton Hears a Who. I had no idea if he would enjoy the movie experience or not. I tried to prepare him as much as I could by explaining that the “TV” was going to be really big and it might be loud. We had been reading the book for a few weeks now in anticipation of doing this one day. I was prepared, though, for the possibility that we would not be staying for the whole thing.
And, well, I have no freakin’ clue how he liked it. He was mesmerized, I can tell you that. I tried to talk to him and ask him questions throughout the film - Did he like it? Was he scared? Did he want to stay? Did he want to sit on my lap? - and he just gave me one-word answers and assured me we should stay. I suppose it’s pretty overwhelming the first time you’re in a movie theater. And of course, my crazy emotional crap kicked in, and I was pretty much choking back tears at the end. Why is it that once you are pregnant and go through that crying phase it still lingers for things like this? Is that true for others too? It rears its head again for the endings of movies and bad TV. It’s ridiculous.
After the movie I asked Sam what his favorite part was. He said it was the part with the eagle. Um, the really scary, vampire-like eagle who attacks Horton and steals the clover, almost killing the people of Whoville? Yeah, that’s the one.
I hope Sam doesn’t wake up screaming in the middle of the night about monkeys trying to cage him. He did eat a great dinner though so he can’t be completely scarred.
















As far as the radioactive bit goes… it really is no big deal. Except it tastes like utter hellish crap and there are usually tears in just trying to get a child to drink it. And the strapping of your baby to the table? Yeah… just as horrific as you imagine. I have done it, and was ABLE to do it because it was a life threatening situation. But on the whim of a doctor without first pursuing a less invasive route? Glad you are done with this doc.
Let me just say also… that the pediatric “findings” from tests like these just kinda blow my mind. As you mentioned, your girlfriends baby who screamed till she puked? Yeah. Reflux. Uh huh. My daughter had a test involving the same radioactive material, only they were x-raying her AS she drank the material. It was called a “Swallow Test” and it was to see if she was aspirating the fluid she was drinking. She refused to drink, and screamed her head off as she was strapped to the upright “chair” they had her on. So they forced the crap down her throat with a syringe. The tech said that she passed with flying colors, as MOST kids would aspirate while being forced to drink while screaming, and she did not. The Speech therapist who had ordered the test decided the test was faulty because it didn’t tell her what she expected to find, and proceeded as though she had aspirated the stuff.
Sorry, this all still pisses me off. I just feel like the sadists who order these tests on a vague possibility, or IGNORE the findings or SKEW the results? ARRRRGH! In-freaking-human! So yeah. We are so done with that above mentioned Therapist, and my baby’s problems ended up fixing themselves and THE END.
I don’t know all the details, but Gray just recently- around 2 yrs old- made it on the charts. He was like, negative 2% for head, 2% for weight, etc. TINY. But you know what? He’s just a little guy. I’ve been assured it has nothing to do with how big he’ll be later in life. He’s healthy, so we couldn’t find any medical reasons for it either. He’s a peanut. He’s the size of my 1 yr old niece (actually I think she might weigh more than him now) and not far off from my friend’s whopping 6 month old. They do come in all shapes and sizes. And I love my little guy. I understand concerns for those that do need some attention in this area, but you know your heart and if all seems ok so far. It probably is.
xoxo
Steph
Sigh… sounds like you need to switch to the other doctor. Or at least make it known to the first one that you are peeved over being misled and instructed to do something that isn’t truly necessary yet.
Good luck on the feeding issues. Good times, eh?
And he’s such a typical boy: loving the violent, scary stuff…
Those damn charts. I didn’t think they hassled you after a kid was over One. Because, really… “Failure to Thrive” doesn’t apply to a “kid” unless maybe they are starving to death… which of course, Sam’s not. It’s bad enough that mothers get hassled so much during their baby’s first year about weight, size and all that stuff, especially when it seems to me that hardly any babies do well according to their ‘charts’. But come on. Some kids are smaller than others. It’s obvious when a kid is dangerously thin and if they’re not then… who cares? By the time Sam is a teenage boy I bet he’ll be all muscular and towering over you and then you’ll laugh at these days…
As for the vaccination schedule. I am sure I am referred to as ‘the crazy lady who delayed her daughter’s MMR until she was over 2 1/2′. But I am okay with that.
That’s just crazy. He certainly doesn’t look like he’s wasting away in any of the pictures. Glorious chubby cheeks do not indicate any kind of eating failure. Is he also on the short side? My ped. usually says something like, “that weight is fine for that height”.
-sorry I have been MIA lately, a series of crazy events has taken place!-
Jack has ALWAYS been small for his age. He looks beefy in photos, but he is turning four on Saturday and he is by FAR the smallest boy in his preschool class and people constantly mistake him for a younger child (until they hear him speak). Don’t pay attention to the charts, all kids are different. Jack eats EVERYTHING and he has tons of energy and lots o’ smarts. Sam seems the same!
We modified our vaccination schedule too, poo on those who judge!
Good luck, your boys look beautiful!
I don’t remember how I stumbled upon your blog, but It caught my eye when I read the title. I want you to know that I have a 28 month old who weighs 22 1/2 and is 31 inches tall(average for a 16 month old)…she’s only gained 5 pounds since she was 9 months old. They have put her through so much. I too did the food log, talked to a nutritionist (I was doing everything right), they took her blood, I had to take in stool samples…blah blah blah…in the end? She’s still not on the charts and they’ve determined that she’s just going to be small!! Hang in there, I know it’s hard. My 6 month old is 18.6 pounds, only 4 pounds lighter than her!! They are both healthy and happy, and I’m sure your boy is too!
You know what? My nine year old weighs about nine pounds more than my six year old and is AT LEAST a head and a half smaller than anyone in his class (and has been every year since he’s been in school) and there’s NOTHING wrong with him.
I’ve been lucky to have a doctor who says “well, every time he comes in he’s a little bit bigger so there’s nothing to worry about” and that’s fine with me.
Even though the other doctor in the practice was much better with you than the horrible test-wanting doctor, I’d leave the practice all together after that. And I’d tell them why.
Don’t beat yourself up over this, just make sure Sam is eating as well as he can and don’t stress on it. He will be fine.
xoxo
If he’s healthy, learning, happy, and otherwise thriving does it matter if he’s small? Some people are small, I’ve observed…
I had the barium test done a few years ago, and it was no picnic for me. I can’t imagine a little kiddo going through it.
Someone has to be at the lower end of the chart or there would be no chart! Grrr. Some of the things doctors do/say drive me straight up the wall.
Keep on trusting your mother instincts. Sounds like Sam is a perfectly healhty boy.
[…] Sam’s first well-check with our new doctor. You may remember our last ped, who wanted us to subject him to a Reflux test for no good reason? And made me pretty much stress about every single ounce he ate at every moment of every day for […]